Category Archives: South Asia
Social Exclusion Case Study: Pakistan
Pakistan is arguably the world’s most important fragile state, but many of its problems are not well understood. Security problems dominate headlines, but the country’s real troubles more often than not float beneath the surface unknown even to those trying to help the country.
A good example of this is the issue of social exclusion. Although it receives almost no attention internationally, social exclusion—in its various forms—plays a major role in the country’s problems. By systematically disadvantaging large portions of its population, Pakistan’s elites reduce the legitimacy of the state, encourage extremism against it, weaken the impetus to enhance public services, and contribute to long-term demographic and environmental threats.
Horizontal social exclusion is one of the two most important drivers (with weak government) of state fragility worldwide, yet rarely receives the attention it deserves in international discussions of fragile states. Whereas vertical inequity between individuals plays a major role in debates on development, horizontal inequity between groups is often not even measured.
A recent Norwegian Peacebuilding Resource Center (NOREF) Policy Brief on social exclusion in Pakistan is therefore a very welcome addition to the literature on the country. By outlining the country’s main axes of social exclusion and how they affect stability and governance, it does a great service to anyone working on the country. I strongly recommend the analysis part of the paper both as a backgrounder for those working on Pakistan and as a case study for how social exclusion affects fragile states in general. (more…)
More on Economic Development, Foreign aid, Governance, Identity, Review, South Asia
Can Foreign Aid Improve Pakistan’s Political Economy?
Like many struggling countries, Pakistan’s two most critical problems are feckless leaders and a feeble state. Can donors do anything to help get such countries’ political economy moving in the right direction?
I recently convened a working group of leading Pakistani development professionals and outside experts at the Global Economic Symposium (GES) to discuss just such this question.
The group’s conclusions are summarized in this report. (more…)
More on Foreign aid, Governance, Politics, South Asia
Promoting Human Rights in non Western Countries
A key challenge faced by those engaged in international human rights policy and practice is adopting an effective framework for protecting and promoting human rights around the world in a way that preserves and articulates their universal nature, while at the same time respecting local values and practices.
One way to approach this challenge is to examine values, norms, customs and practices in non-Western cultures which can act as ‘receptors’ for human rights principles and practice. A new Dutch collaborative research project adopts just such an approach (and is thus called the ‘Receptor Approach’). It brings together experts from around the world and from a variety of disciplines – law, anthropology, sociology, political science, international relations and philosophy among others. (more…)
More on Africa, East Asia, Middle East and North Africa, Policies, Poverty, Religion, South Asia
Language Policy and Development: Lost in Translation
Language is one of the most neglected areas in the development field. It barely registers on any agenda to help poor countries despite its importance to a number of crucial areas and it being a barrier to progress in many fragile states. Why is this? (more…)
More on Africa, Economic Development, Policies, Politics, South Asia
Strengthening the Rule of Law in Developing Countries
Many fragile states suffer from incoherent legal systems. Whereas in developed countries, one single system exists and is effectively enforced, in fragile states multiple systems work side-by-side, each weakly enforced, and often operating in contradiction with each other. Creating a unified and robust system of law is one of the biggest challenges these countries face.
In most cases, this incoherence is a direct product of colonialism. One system, often with the greatest relevancy to local populations, has roots in the precolonial system of governance. It may have evolved a lot since then, but is still based on local circumstances and institutions. The state, itself a product of foreign rule, follows another system, based on Western legal tradition, imported from abroad. Neither is consistently or equitably implemented. Corruption distorts outcomes. Officials (whether those of the state or local leaders) lack training. Favoritism is common.
In some places, religion comes into play with its own system (such as Sharia), creating three legal layers, each with its own logic. Outcomes and incentives can be widely divergent. Local systems may also vary tremendously by location, creating a complex mosaic of different mixes of different systems depending where in a country one is. (more…)
Recent Articles on Fragile States Worth Reading
See below for links on the DRC, Burundi, Pakistan, Azerbaijan, Mauritania, Libya, the relationship between ethnicity and corruption, a new synthesis of recent research, and the new structural economics. (more…)
More on Africa, Central Asia, Conflict and Security, South Asia
Best Recent Book on Pakistan for Policymakers
Quite a number of books on Pakistan have been published in recent years. The best for policymakers working on development issues in the country is Pakistan: Beyond the ‘Crisis State’, edited by Maleeha Lodhi.
Written exclusively by leading Pakistanis, it looks beyond the headlines that dominate Western perceptions of Pakistan in examining the country’s myriad challenges. Individual chapters focus on the state, energy, economic management, competitiveness, education, ideology, the civil service, the army, and relations with Afghanistan and India. It is comprehensive, going well beyond what other books cover and in greater detail. (The downside of this approach is that some of the chapters are too policy oriented for the average reader.) (more…)
More on Foreign aid, Fragile States, Governance, Politics, Review, South Asia
How Myanmar (Burma)’s Ethnic Diversity Holds Back Democracy
The biggest problem facing Myanmar (Burma) today is not its lack of democracy, but its lack of peace. Since World War II, the country has experienced almost continuous conflict, with more sustained and diverse ethnic insurgencies than any other place in the world. This history has had devastating consequences for its politics, economy, and infrastructure. Introducing a set of policies that ends the insurgencies is a prerequisite for advancing democracy and development.
There are a number of things that differentiates Myanmar and its 60 million people from its far more successful Southeast Asian neighbors—and explain why its history is so different from theirs. (more…)
More on Conflict and Security, East Asia, Fragile States, Governance, Identity, Maps, South Asia
Is Corruption Evil?
Cross-posted at Global Dashboard.
Corruption is generally vilified as an unmitigated evil. It disenfranchises the poor, weakens public services, reduces investment, and holds back whole societies. And yet, in some instances, corruption can actually be very useful, lubricating business in a way that promotes growth, creates jobs, helps smooth the introduction of needed reforms, and reduces poverty.
What explains this paradox? (more…)
Is Pakistan an Emerging Market?
Cross-posted from Global Dashboard
Most people in the West believe that Pakistan is an unstable country on the verge of imminent collapse or an explosion of violence. It is consistently portrayed—by politicians, policymakers, and the media—as the most dangerous and dysfunctional state in the world, struggling with terrorism, an out-of-control military, and interreligious conflict.
And yet, Pakistan is included on Goldman Sachs’ list of the next eleven (N-11) most important emerging markets. Although it has (along with Nigeria and Bangladesh) “broad and systematic issues across a range of areas” that will prevent it from fully delivering on its growth potential, the country’s large population (it currently has 180 million people) assures its inclusion. Indeed, within a generation, Pakistan will have the fourth largest number of people in the world, behind only India, China, and the United States, and be a market too significant to ignore. (more…)
More on Economic Development, Foreign aid, Investing, South Asia
